Alberta By-election Is a Minefield for Poilievre
Conservative leader will be an island of federalism in a sea of independence
Conservative Party of Canada (CPC) leader Pierre Poilievre probably thought he would be crazy not to accept the offer of CPC MP Damien Kurek to step aside in his Alberta riding of Battle River-Crowfoot. The rural constituency has long literally been one of the top two safest seats for Conservatives. But it’s not that simple.
It might have been better if one of the two CPC MPs in rural seats immediately outside of Ottawa had offered their seats to Poilievre. It would have meant less dislocation for Poilievre’s family and no worries about walking into the minefield of Alberta independence, which is already the major source of conversation in the province months ahead of the anticipated referendum on independence that separation advocates are preparing for the municipal elections in the early fall. True, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has promised to put the question to voters in 2026, but members of the Alberta Progress Project (APP) are not content to wait until then, believing it is better to strike while they have the momentum. And momentum is precisely what they have at the moment.
Just as Smith cannot be seen to be personally supporting independence but merely approving of the right of Albertans to decide their future, Poilievre must stand as a staunch federalist while a majority of his supporters will be embracing independence. It will make the by-election campaign — which the People’s Party of Canada plan to contest with a candidate — a difficult road for Poilievre.
Either enough Canadians had the good sense to turf Carney and the Liberals after a decade of catastrophic government and elect a Conservative alternative, or the country was going to break up.
The premier is already facing the same dilemma as 56% of United Conservative Party voters are supporting independence. With support for separation growing, it is certain that a fairly sizable majority of CPC voters in Alberta — and especially in the Battle River-Crowfoot riding — will be in favor of independence. That will put Poilievre exactly where he was during the last election campaign: never quite fulfilling the political expectations of principled conservatives who think both Poilievre and the party tend to appease so-called moderates and avoid taking hard core ideological positions.
But, as he’s running for a federal party seeking a seat in the federal House of Commons, he can’t do otherwise.
Obviously, Poilievre can’t and won’t lose this by-election. He can’t because that would be the end of his political ambition and he won’t because even if 30% of CPC voters don’t cast a ballot, the Liberals, NDP and PPC cannot hope to galvanize enough of their base to be victorious. But it could still mark the end of Poilievre’s dream of becoming prime minister, the end of the Conservative Party as a viable political force and the end of Canada as the country we now know it.
It was clear during this sham election campaign, with Prime Minister Mark Carney feigning outrage over President Donald Trump and pretending to fume over US tariffs, that we had come to a fork in the road. Either enough Canadians had the good sense to turf Carney and the Liberals after a decade of catastrophic government and elect a Conservative alternative, or the country was going to break up. Alberta has had enough and when if it leaves Confederation, other provinces are sure to follow. The arrogant Liberals think their mendacious performance won them another mandate to continue to kick Canadians in the ass, but all they succeeded in doing was sealing their own fate and that of Canada.
Carney has put together what is perhaps the most inept excuse for a federal cabinet in Canadian history and is governing with the same arrogance and insouciance as his moronic predecessor. He doesn’t get the seriousness of the situation — or perhaps he does and never really intended to govern Canada but merely preside over its dissolution.
Audiobook for paid Substack subscribers. Perfect Present for Friends & Family.
1984 The Audio Book: Complete Chapters with Commentary: David Krayden Reads George Orwell's 1984 Podcast
NEW! MERCH WITH A MESSAGE
NEW Stand on Guard Merch with a Message Now available in our Stand on Guard Store. These products are available & ready to ship to Canada and the United States.
Original Triger Stickers & Fridge Magnets (5 per page, 7 designs to choose from)
No Farmers No Food (Hoodie)
Freedom Convoy 2022 (Tee & Hoodie & Stickers)
Think While Its Still Legal (Tee & Hoodie & Sticker)
Resolve to Resist (Hoodie & Tee & Sticker)
NEW I am a Canadian Tee (Diefenbaker)
NEW Cups (4 designs)
NEW Stand on Guard designs: Cup, Cap, Tee, Touques
Let us know what you think? We are new to this so thank you for your patience!
NEW Show your support for Independent Journalism!
If you love free speech, you will love this new "I heart Free Speech" Stand on Guard mug. By popular demand we have included on this mug "Resolve to Resist with Krayden's Right"
Join David Krayden for the Stand on Guard Podcast.
David Krayden does daily livestream broadcasts at 10:00 AM ET to bring you the latest news from Ottawa and around the world. Everything you won't hear on the mainstream media.
JOIN THE KRAYDEN’S RIGHT RESISTANCE
Freedom of the Press is NOT cheap. If you believe in independent media and the stories I am covering, you can support me in the following voluntary paid subscriber and membership options, starting at around $5 on the following socials:
You can now find Stand on Guard with David Krayden now on most podcasts:
Send tips and comments to David Krayden on X DM: @davidkrayden
Alberta ( where he was born and raised ) will understand they have a better chance to achieve their goals with Pierre Poilievre a strong decent intelligent true Canadian as Prime Minister. Biggest threat to him and any decent politician today is the sham electoral process built for interference and many Canadians who just don’t seem to care that hurts us all. Poilievre deserves to be PM and Canada deserves a true leader!
Albertans don’t want to leave their country, they just want what is fair and to be able to prosper. PP will be welcome here.